The new issue of the New Yorker has a feature about David Simon, the creator of the HBO series The Wire. If you’ve been around me for more than five minutes in the last year, I’d be shocked if you haven’t heard me proselytizing the show in grandiose terms, comparing Simon to the second coming of Shakespeare and calling it the greatest artistic achievement in the history of moving pictures. Well, for once I wasn’t using hyperbole. The show really is that good and David Simon really is that brilliant.
This article is quite easily the best piece yet written about Simon and his creation. It makes it quite clear that Simon sought to redefine what a television show was capable of from the outset; he set out to create something more provocative, more probing, more visceral, and bleaker than anything else ever attempted on TV.
Simon makes it clear that the show’s ambitions were grand. “ ‘The Wire’ is dissent,” he says. “It is perhaps the only storytelling on television that overtly suggests that our political and economic and social constructs are no longer viable, that our leadership has failed us relentlessly, and that no, we are not going to be all right.” He also likes to say that “The Wire” is a story about the “decline of the American empire.” Simon’s belief in the show is a formidable thing, and it leads him into some ostentatious comparisons that he sometimes laughs at himself for and sometimes does not. Recently, he spoke at Loyola College, in Baltimore; he described the show in lofty terms that left many of the students in the audience puzzled—at least, those who had come hoping to hear how they might get a job in Hollywood. In creating “The Wire,” Simon said, he and his colleagues had “ripped off the Greeks: Sophocles, Aeschylus, Euripides. Not funny boy—not Aristophanes. We’ve basically taken the idea of Greek tragedy and applied it to the modern city-state.” He went on, “What we were trying to do was take the notion of Greek tragedy, of fated and doomed people, and instead of these Olympian gods, indifferent, venal, selfish, hurling lightning bolts and hitting people in the ass for no reason—instead of those guys whipping it on Oedipus or Achilles, it’s the postmodern institutions . . . those are the indifferent gods.”
Nowhere is this ambition more apparent than in the second season’s tragic chronicle of the fall of Frank Sobotka, the beleaguered boss of Baltimore’s increasingly marginalized longshoremen, as he struggles to sustain the livelihood of his men through morally dubious dealings with organized crime. As the season winds down, Frank finds himself broken and helpless, but he clings to his identity in the face of his delinquent son’s sobbing: “You’re more like me than you know. You’re a Sobotka.” In Simon’s world, this is how people persevere against the institutional hurricane into which they’re helplessly cast - they play the part they know. Bubbles keeps copping vials and running capers, Omar keeps rippin’ and runnin’, Bodie keeps being the good soldier, the narcos doing street rips, Clay Davis keeps taking money, and the American city keeps dying.
But despite the dreary subject matter, The Wire manages to maintain a sense of lightness.
If Simon’s characters were to deliver the kind of doomy social criticism that Simon does, “The Wire” would, as he likes to say, “lay there like a bagel.” Fortunately, his characters bristle with humor, quirks, private sorrows; his drug dealers express intricate opinions about Baltimore radio stations, chicken nuggets, and chess.
The human condition isn’t all sadness and sorrow, after all. The show’s world-weary pathos easily drifts into warm, deeply-felt humor when Bunk’s one night stands ends in drunken mumbling and a pink bathrobe or Omar schools a court clerk in Greek mythology.
The bottom line is that The Wire is drama on a level that few works have ever approached. If it were only about the deft hand with which Simon weaves the staggering number of plot threads, it would still be a vital creation, but its blow by blow dissection of contemporary urban America, pulling no punches and landing every single blow with surgical precision, makes it a masterwork on a historic scale. Watch it because my ramblings can’t possibly do it justice.